Maximizing Coaching Impact: Choosing Between Online and In-Person Sessions
The available studies show no significant gap in effectiveness between online and in-person coaching. The choice comes down to your topic, the space you have, screen fatigue and confidentiality.
8 min readUpdated on

Online and in-person coaching rest on the same work, and the available studies show no significant gap in effectiveness between them. The choice comes down to practical criteria: the topic you want to work on, whether you have a place to speak freely, how well you tolerate screens, and how far away the coach is.
Is online coaching as effective as in-person coaching?
Two meta-analyses have asked that question about coaching at work. The first, by Jones, Woods and Guillaume, was published in 2016 in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology and is listed by Aston University. It pools 17 studies. The authors found that the effect of coaching did not vary with format when they compared face-to-face coaching with blended setups that combine face-to-face and e-coaching.
The second, published in October 2023 in Frontiers in Psychology (Cannon-Bowers and colleagues), compares the two modes head to head: 9 face-to-face studies (effect size g = 0.48) and 2 virtual studies (g = 0.35). The difference between the two groups is not statistically significant, and the authors read this as support for remote coaching. The limit is visible in the numbers themselves: the comparison rests on only two virtual studies, which calls for caution.
What this research allows us to say: nothing currently shows that one format beats the other on average, in a work setting. What it does not say: that both are equal for you, on your topic, with your coach. An average does not describe a person. Format is therefore a matter of comfort and feasibility, to be settled after the main question: the criteria for identifying a reliable coach.
What actually differs between a video session and a session in an office
The work is the same either way: a goal set at the start, questions, and commitments carried from one session to the next. The difference lies in the physical setting, and that is where your decision is made.
| Criterion | Online | In person |
|---|---|---|
| Travel | None: the session fits between two meetings | A round trip, which also works as a buffer before and after |
| Choice of coach | Open to any specialty, whatever the city | Limited to coaches based near your home or office |
| Where the session happens | Your own space: you need a room where nobody can hear | The coach's office, or a neutral room away from your workplace |
| Nonverbal cues | Face and voice, within the camera frame | The whole body, the silences, how you walk in and sit down |
| Fatigue | Screen-specific load, especially after a day of video calls | Travel fatigue, depending on distance |
| Technology | Depends on the connection and the tool used | No technical dependency |
Video is no longer a fallback. According to the 2021 snapshot survey by the International Coaching Federation (10,445 responses from 148 countries and territories), 83% of coaches had increased their use of audio-video platforms during the pandemic, and 82% reported a decrease in in-person sessions. Many coaches have therefore practised remote sessions. You can ask yours how long they have worked online and how often.
Then there is cost. The fee for a session depends on the coach and on who is paying far more than on the format. What video does remove is your travel time and travel expenses, which add up over an engagement lasting several months. For price ranges, see our breakdown of professional coaching fees.
Screen fatigue and confidentiality: the two limits of video to plan for
Screen fatigue was described by Jeremy Bailenson, a professor at Stanford, in a theoretical article published in 2021 in the journal Technology, Mind and Behavior and summarised by Futurity. He puts forward four causes: close-up, continuous eye contact, seeing your own image all the time, reduced mobility in front of the camera, and a heavier mental load to send and read nonverbal signals. The author states that these arguments still need to be tested experimentally.
His fixes are simple and apply to a coaching session: shrink the window, hide your self-view, move the camera further away so that you can move, and take audio-only breaks. If you already spend the whole day on video calls, book the session in the morning or go in person.
Confidentiality plays out on two levels. The first is the tool. The French data protection authority, the CNIL, in guidance dated 9 April 2020, advises users to read the terms of use, favour systems that protect privacy, check for end-to-end encryption and close the application after use. The second is the place: a session taken from an open-plan office or a shared living room limits what you will dare to say.
On the coach's side, the duty does not change with the format. The ICF Code of Ethics, effective since 1 April 2025, requires its members to maintain the strictest level of confidentiality, to store and dispose of records securely, electronic files and communications included, and to meet their obligations through any technology systems they use, artificial intelligence among them. It also provides for an agreement to be set before coaching begins, confidentiality included. So ask which tool is used, whether sessions are recorded and where notes are kept.
Which format fits your situation?
Start from your real constraints, not from a preference held on principle.
- You live far from a large city or travel often: online coaching widens the choice. You can search by specialty instead of by address, for example among professional coaches.
- You have nowhere to talk without being overheard: the coach's office solves the problem. Look at coaches based near you, for example coaches in Paris or coaches in Lyon.
- Your days are already filled with video calls: a session in person, or failing that by audio only, gives you a break from the screen.
- Your topic involves physical presence (public speaking, how you carry yourself in meetings): in a room, the coach sees the whole body and not just a framed face.
- The coaching is for a team: bringing everyone into the same room avoids switched-off cameras. If the team is spread out, remote work remains workable with a team coach used to that setting.
- Your employer is paying: check what the contract says about format and location. Our article on how to fund professional coaching covers the possible arrangements.
Nothing forces you to decide once and for all. You can agree on a first meeting in person followed by remote sessions, or the reverse, provided it is written into the initial agreement along with the planned rhythm. On that last point, see how many coaching sessions to plan for.
One last marker, true in both formats: coaching is not care. If what you are facing is psychological distress or a health problem, the right person to see is a health professional, online or in an office. Our article on the difference between coaching and therapy helps you place your need.
Sources
- Aston University: Jones, Woods and Guillaume, "The effectiveness of workplace coaching", Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 2016.
- Frontiers in Psychology: Cannon-Bowers and colleagues, "Workplace coaching: a meta-analysis and recommendations for advancing the science of coaching", 2023.
- International Coaching Federation: results of the 2021 snapshot survey.
- Futurity: republication of the Stanford release on Jeremy Bailenson's work, 24 February 2021.
- CNIL: advice on using videoconferencing tools, 9 April 2020 (in French).
- ICF: Code of Ethics effective since 1 April 2025.
Frequently asked questions
Is online coaching cheaper than in-person coaching?
None of the sources we consulted compares fees by format. The price of a session depends on the coach, their specialty and who is paying (an individual or a company). What video removes is your travel time and travel expenses. Ask the coach for both rates before you commit, and compare over the full length of the engagement.
Can you alternate online and in-person sessions?
Yes, if the coach agrees. The meta-analysis by Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016) compared face-to-face coaching with blended setups and observed no difference in effect. One possible arrangement is to meet in person at the start, then continue remotely. Set the split in the initial agreement, so that last-minute changes do not disrupt the work.
How do you prepare for a coaching session by video?
Pick a closed room where nobody can hear you, test sound and connection a few minutes ahead, and switch off notifications. To limit fatigue, shrink the window and hide your self-view, as Jeremy Bailenson (Stanford, 2021) suggests. Keep something to take notes with, and plan a screen-free moment right after the session.
Is confidentiality the same online?
The coach's duty is the same: the ICF Code of Ethics, effective since 1 April 2025, covers electronic files and digital tools for its members. The practical risk is of a different kind: the video tool, recording, people nearby who can hear. Ask which tool is used, whether the session is recorded and where notes are kept.
Is a phone session, with no video, an option?
Yes, if the coach offers it. Without an image you lose facial expressions, but you can walk around or look elsewhere, which eases the load described by Jeremy Bailenson, who himself recommends audio-only breaks. Try this format on a first conversation before adopting it for the whole engagement.
Ready to take action?
Find the coach who matches your goal
Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.


