EraCoach
Coaching professionnel

Unveiling the Impact: Professional Coaching's ROI Insights from Research

Controlled trials and meta-analyses show that coaching can improve some behaviors at work. None of the studies read here supports a universal financial return: it depends on what you measure.

E

7 min readUpdated on

Unveiling the Impact: Professional Coaching's ROI Insights from Research

Professional coaching has documented effects on performance and behavior at work, but none of the studies read here establishes a universal financial return. Its value depends on the goal set at the start, the quality of the relationship with the coach, and how change is measured.

What does research say about coaching effectiveness?

The strongest evidence comes from controlled trials and meta-analyses, which pool several studies. The 2016 meta-analysis by Rebecca Jones, Stephen Woods and Yves Guillaume in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology examines the effects of coaching on performance and other learning and development outcomes. It also looks at which techniques and features of coaching change those effects. Its starting point is plain: despite the growth of workplace coaching, scientific evidence on its benefits to organizations was scarce, and expected outcomes were often poorly specified.

Another study, published in 2019 by Erik de Haan, David Gray and Sally Bonneywell in Academy of Management Learning and Education, involved 180 coachees, 66 coaches and 140 line managers in a global healthcare corporation. The authors describe it as the largest randomized controlled trial in executive coaching to their knowledge. They report substantial effects on some measures, and significant effects on coachee self-efficacy and resilience.

These studies describe effects on behaviors and perceptions. They do not say that a person or a company will get a given result: coaching guarantees nothing.

Why are coaching ROI figures hard to verify?

The formula is simple: ROI = (benefits achieved - coaching costs) / coaching costs x 100. The difficulty lies in the benefits. In an October 2026 article by Tim Morin, the author explains that you must decide which benefits to count and how much of the change to attribute to coaching. If sales rise after an engagement, part of the credit may belong to pricing, a new product, the market or the sales team.

He adds that when the coach, the coaching company or the sponsor chooses both the benefit and the attribution percentage, the result can quickly become self-serving. That is why eye-catching ROI claims are hard to audit. He also notes that a 2023 meta-analysis of 37 randomized controlled studies found a meaningful overall effect, without producing a universal five-, seven- or ten-times financial return.

The practical consequence: be wary of a return percentage given without a method, a period or an open source. A single figure does not tell you who calculated it, on what sample, or how much was attributed to coaching.

Is coaching worth it for a company?

It depends on what the company wants to change. The CIPD, the UK professional body for HR, states in its coaching factsheet that coaching is one of the most effective approaches according to its learning at work report. It also specifies that coaching is one intervention among many, is not the answer to every development need, and should be used only when it is clearly the best way to help someone learn and develop.

The CIPD lists situations where it suits well: helping a technical expert build interpersonal skills such as handling conflict, supporting an individual's potential and career, or developing a more strategic outlook after promotion to a senior role.

Morin also points out that if retention is already strong and a leader is coached to sharpen strategic judgment, justifying the engagement with turnover savings tells us little. The right indicator is the one tied to the reason coaching was commissioned. For leaders, our article on executive coaching details the framework.

What makes the effect of coaching vary?

The trial by de Haan and colleagues argues that the elements common to all approaches matter most, and that the quality of the working alliance between coach and coachee is the best single predictor. That alliance partly explained effects on well-being and perceived social support.

For someone looking for a coach, this shifts the question: method matters, but the relationship matters a great deal. A discovery session lets you test it before committing, and our article on quality criteria for a professional coach helps you prepare that conversation. On credentials, see the added value of ICF, EMCC and HEC certifications.

The January 2009 Harvard Business Review survey of 140 leading coaches points the same way: it describes a field where measuring effectiveness remains fragile and views differ on useful qualifications. It dates from 2009 and reflects the market of that time, but its point on measurement remains useful for knowing what to ask a coach.

How can you assess the return of coaching before you commit?

A serious approach is set up before the first session. Morin recommends starting from the business reason and two or three target behaviors, setting a baseline, combining several signals (a behavioral signal, stakeholder feedback, an operating outcome), testing alternative explanations, and reporting contribution rather than invented causation. He advises giving a range rather than one single percentage, and protecting trust by collecting only what was agreed.

  1. Define a precise goal: a behavior or a work situation, not a slogan.
  2. Choose a qualified coach and check their background, on the executive coach or leadership coach page depending on the need.
  3. Set indicators before you start and record the starting point.
  4. Keep session confidentiality separate from reporting to the employer.
  5. Review the outcome at the end without crediting coaching for what has other causes.

For duration and cost, see how many sessions to plan and what professional coaching costs. HR leaders will find a complementary method in measuring coaching ROI in the company.

Frequently asked questions

Does professional coaching have a proven return on investment?

Controlled trials and meta-analyses report effects on performance and some behaviors. None of the sources read here demonstrates a universal financial return. The return depends on the goal, the context and the calculation method, and it is hard to separate from other causes.

Can you calculate the ROI of coaching?

Yes, with the formula (benefits - costs) / costs x 100. The difficulty is choosing which benefits to count and how much to attribute to coaching. The more those choices are made by whoever sells or commissions the engagement, the less reliable the figure.

Is coaching right for every development need?

No. According to the CIPD, it is one intervention among many and should be chosen only when it is clearly the best way to help someone learn and develop. Compare it with other options, such as training.

What makes coaching effective?

The 2019 trial by de Haan, Gray and Bonneywell argues that elements common to all approaches matter most, and that the alliance between coach and coachee predicts effects best. A discovery session helps you judge that relationship.

Does coaching replace therapy?

No. Coaching targets professional goals and neither diagnoses nor treats. If a difficulty is a health matter, a health professional is the right contact. Our guide coaching or psychology helps you decide.

Sources

Did you find this article helpful? Share it.

Partager :

Ready to take action?

Find the coach who matches your goal

Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.

Find a coach

Find a coach in these cities