EraCoach
Leadership

From Busy to Effective: A Coach's Guide to Operational Leadership

Measuring the impact of coaching means comparing, before and after, indicators agreed with the coach at the start. Satisfaction at the end matters, but it does not prove that anything changed.

E

9 min readUpdated on

From Busy to Effective: A Coach's Guide to Operational Leadership

To measure the impact of coaching, compare where you stood before and after against indicators agreed with the coach at the start: observable behaviours at work, goals met or missed and, in a company setting, effects on the team. Satisfaction at the end matters, but it does not prove that anything changed.

What can you actually measure in a coaching engagement?

Coaching leaves traces of different kinds: what the person thought of it, what they understood, what they now do differently, and what that changes around them. The model published by Kirkpatrick Partners, built to evaluate training, separates exactly these four levels: reaction, learning, behaviour, results. It was not written for coaching, but it transfers easily and keeps you from mistaking a pleasant memory for a real effect.

LevelWhat the model measuresThe question to ask about your coaching
ReactionDoes the participant find the experience favourable, engaging and relevant?Did the sessions feel useful for my work?
LearningDid they acquire the intended knowledge, skills, confidence and commitment?What do I understand or know how to do that I did not before?
BehaviourDo they perform the critical behaviours on the job?What do I do differently, and who can see it?
ResultsDo the targeted organisational outcomes occur?What has changed for my team or my project?

A satisfaction form filled in at the last session only covers the first level. To go further, you need to have decided in advance what will be observed at levels three and four, and by whom.

Inside a company, measurement runs on two planes at once. The factsheet from the CIPD, the UK professional body for HR and people development, notes that workplace coaching has both organisational and individual goals. An honest review looks at both, without claiming that one follows automatically from the other. For the financial side, see our article on measuring the return on investment of coaching in a company.

Which indicators should you set before the first session?

Measurement is decided at the contracting stage. The Code of Ethics of the International Coaching Federation (ICF), in effect since April 1, 2025, asks the coach to co-create, before coaching begins, an agreement with the client and any sponsor covering roles, responsibilities, confidentiality and financial arrangements. The ICF Core Competencies add that coach and client develop agreements that frame each session and ensure alignment on goals, logistics and expectations.

In practice, the question to settle with the coach in your very first conversation is plain: how will I know, and how will others know, that this coaching was worth doing? If the coach does not ask it, ask it yourself. A useful indicator meets four conditions:

  • It describes an observable fact. "My deputy now prepares the committee papers" can be checked; "I delegate better" cannot.
  • It has a starting point. Write down the current situation before you begin, or no comparison will be possible later.
  • It depends mostly on you. Revenue or staff departures in a team also depend on the market, the organisation and colleagues.
  • Someone else can confirm it. A line manager, a peer or a direct report sees what self-assessment misses.

Two or three indicators of this kind are enough, provided at least one concerns a behaviour visible at work. A business figure can be one of them if it already exists in your reporting and if you accept that it does not depend on coaching alone. Our list of questions to prepare for a first coaching session helps you word these criteria, and how a coach handles them is one of the quality criteria for a professional coach. To compare profiles on this point, the professional coaches page lets you open several profiles before getting in touch.

How do you track progress while the coaching is under way?

Waiting until the end to measure throws away the best opportunity to adjust. Three simple tools fit on a single page:

  1. A repeated self-assessment. The same grid, with the same scale, completed at the start, at the midpoint and at the end. What counts is the gap between readings, not the score itself.
  2. A log of facts. Between sessions, note the situations where you acted differently, and those where the old reflex came back. The log feeds the next session and documents the behaviour level of the table above.
  3. A midpoint review. Halfway through, reread the starting indicators with your coach: which are moving, which were badly chosen, which should be replaced.

This follow-up matches what the ICF describes in its competencies: supporting clients in translating insights into action steps, encouraging accountability and celebrating progress along the way.

Feedback from the people around you (colleagues, manager, direct reports) complements self-assessment, but it is not enough by itself. In the meta-analysis by Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016), published in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology and listed by Aston University, coaching that used multisource feedback showed smaller positive effects than coaching that did not. The same study found no significant difference by format (face to face, blended or remote) or by the duration of the coaching. Both points are covered in our articles on how many coaching sessions to plan and on choosing between online and in-person coaching.

Does coaching have a demonstrated effect? What two meta-analyses say

Two research syntheses give an order of magnitude. According to Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen (2014) in The Journal of Positive Psychology, with the record available in the University of Amsterdam repository, coaching in an organisational context has significant positive effects on five categories of individual outcomes: performance and skills, well-being, coping, work attitudes and goal-directed self-regulation. Effect sizes range from g = 0.43 (coping) to g = 0.74 (goal-directed self-regulation).

According to Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016), whose record is published by Aston University, an analysis of 17 studies of coaching delivered by internal or external coaches found a positive overall effect on organisational outcomes (δ = 0.36). The authors conclude that these effect sizes support the potential utility of coaching in organisations.

These figures are group averages drawn from a limited number of studies. They say that the approach produces a measurable effect on average; they say nothing about what a given engagement will produce for a given person. That is one more reason to measure yours against your own indicators.

How do you report to the employer without breaking confidentiality?

When the company pays, it wants to know what the coaching delivered. The ICF Code of Ethics uses the word sponsor for the entity or individual paying for, arranging or defining the coaching services. It requires the coach to maintain the strictest level of confidentiality with all parties involved, and to have a clear agreement about what information is exchanged among them and how. The CIPD likewise recommends agreeing guidelines on confidentiality and information flow to build trust between the individual, the coach and other stakeholders such as managers or HR.

In practice, the report given to the employer covers the goals and indicators agreed at the outset, never the content of the sessions. It works best when the person coached presents it, in a closing meeting with the same participants as the kick-off meeting. Three items are enough: what was aimed for, what was observed for each indicator, and what remains to be worked on.

For an executive or a member of a leadership team, these ground rules are negotiated before signing: raise the point when you look through the executive coaches profiles. An HR lead setting up a programme for several managers can fix the rules once for everyone as part of a leadership development programme.

Frequently asked questions

Can you calculate the return on investment of coaching?

You can estimate it; you can rarely prove it. A business figure depends on many factors besides coaching: market, organisation, team. The calculation is still useful when it rests on an indicator chosen before the start, with its baseline value, and when the review states what can reasonably be attributed to the coaching and what cannot.

When should you measure: during or after the coaching?

Both, and before as well. Without a baseline there is nothing to compare against. A midpoint review lets you correct badly chosen indicators. A reading at the final session gives the overall picture. A last look a few months later, alone or with the coach, shows whether the new behaviours hold once the support has stopped.

Who evaluates the coaching: the person coached, the coach or the employer?

The person coached comes first, because only they know everything that has changed. The coach brings the method and keeps track of the goals. The employer, when it pays, evaluates what was agreed with it at the outset, on the basis of a report that does not reveal what was said in the sessions.

Can coaching without a numerical goal be evaluated?

Yes. A goal such as self-confidence or clarity about a career move can be measured through facts: a speaking slot accepted, a decision made, an application sent. A self-assessment repeated with the same grid shows the change over time. The lack of a number does not prevent measurement; the lack of a starting point does.

What should you do if the indicators are not moving?

Raise it at the midpoint review rather than waiting for the end. There are three possible explanations: the indicator was badly chosen, the goal changed along the way, or the approach does not suit you. In the first two cases, you reword. In the third, stopping or changing coach is legitimate: no coaching guarantees a result.

Sources

Sources

Did you find this article helpful? Share it.

Partager :

Ready to take action?

Find the coach who matches your goal

Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.

Find a coach

Find a coach in these cities