The Inside-Out Approach to Authentic Leadership Development
Personal initiative is work behavior that is self-starting, anticipates problems and overcomes obstacles. Leaders build it by modelling it and by setting a clear frame in which proposing ideas and making mistakes carries no penalty.
9 min readUpdated on

Personal initiative is work behavior that is self-starting, anticipates problems and overcomes obstacles to reach a goal, as defined by psychologists Michael Frese and Doris Fay (2001). Developing it as a leader means two things: modelling it yourself, and giving your team a clear frame in which proposing ideas and making mistakes carries no penalty.
This page is for managers, executives and HR leads who want their teams to propose and act without waiting for every instruction. It covers what the concept means, what tends to suppress it, what a leader can change in how they lead, and when working with a coach makes sense.
What is personal initiative at work?
The concept has clear authors. In a chapter of the Research in Organizational Behavior series, Michael Frese and Doris Fay (2001) define it as work behavior that is self-starting and proactive and that overcomes barriers to achieve a goal. They describe it through four phases of action: the goals people set, the information they seek, the plans they build and the feedback they look for afterwards. They also argue that standard models of job performance are too reactive, focused mainly on how well people carry out what they are asked to do.
Three features set initiative apart from plain autonomy:
| Feature | With initiative | Passive stance |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | The goal comes from the person | The person waits for instructions |
| Time horizon | Anticipates problems before they arrive | Reacts once the problem is there |
| When blocked | Looks for another route | Stops and escalates |
An example: a customer service rep notices that the same complaints come in every Monday. They trace the cause, suggest a fix to the process and come back to their manager with a two-week trial. Nobody asked, and the move stays aligned with the team's goals. That alignment is what turns individual behavior into a leadership lever: useful initiative is not doing whatever you like, it is acting inside a frame everyone understands.
Why initiative cannot be ordered into a team
Taking initiative means exposing yourself: offering an idea that may be turned down, flagging a problem others missed, trying something that may fail. When Google studied its own teams in Project Aristotle, it identified, across 180 teams (115 engineering teams and 65 sales teams), five dynamics that set effective teams apart, according to its Google re:Work guide, first published in 2015. The first is psychological safety, using researcher Amy Edmondson's definition: a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. The others are dependability, structure and clarity, meaning, and impact.
Read through the lens of initiative, that finding points to the most common blockers:
- Fear of mistakes. One of the survey statements published by Google re:Work addresses exactly this: if I make a mistake on our team, it is not held against me. Where mistakes are held against people, they quickly learn to try nothing.
- Vague goals and limits. Without knowing what is expected or how far they can go, people who propose something are guessing.
- Sign-off at every step. When everything goes back to the manager, the team concludes that initiative belongs to the manager alone.
- No response. A proposal that gets no answer discourages the next one.
How leaders build initiative in their team
It starts with you. A leader who waits for every decision from above before moving sends a signal no speech can offset. It continues with the frame you set and the way you ask questions. The steps below follow the four phases Frese and Fay describe (goal, information, plan, feedback):
- Set the what and the why, leave the how. State the expected outcome, the budget and the non-negotiable constraints (legal, ethical, financial), then let the team choose the route.
- Delegate a real decision. Say plainly what the person can decide alone, what they should flag and what still needs approval.
- Swap answers for questions. "What do you recommend?", "What have you tried?", "What could go wrong?" push people to gather information and build a plan.
- Create room to experiment. A limited scope in which to test an idea, followed by a debrief about what was learned rather than who was at fault.
- Answer every proposal. Yes, no or not now, with the reason: feedback is what closes the loop.
This stance is close to that of the leader as coach, who develops the team through questions. It also requires clarity about who owns what: the distinction between responsibility and accountability in leadership helps settle who decides and who answers for the outcome. And it relies on a sense of responsibility in leadership, the other side of initiative: owning what happens after you start something.
A simple first move: at your next team meeting, ask an open question about a recurring operational irritant, give two or three people a deadline to propose a fix, and commit to answering them without rewriting their proposal for them.
Can personal initiative be learned?
Research treats it as behavior rather than a fixed trait, and has put that to the test. A randomized controlled trial published in Academy of Management Learning and Education by Glaub, Frese, Fischer and Hoppe (2014) followed 100 small business owners in Kampala, Uganda. One group took a three-day program based on action regulation theory, the other served as a waiting-list control group. Over the following twelve months the authors measured an increase in initiative behavior and in entrepreneurial success, with the rise in success fully explained by the rise in initiative.
Two caveats matter. This was training, not coaching, delivered to entrepreneurs in a specific setting: its results do not carry over directly to a team of managers in Europe or North America. What it does show is that initiative can be worked on through explicit action principles, which is a reason to practise it rather than wait for it to appear.
What a coach brings to developing initiative
The International Coaching Federation (ICF) defines coaching as partnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential. Applied to initiative, the coach does not make decisions for you: they help you spot what in your leadership style holds back your team's proposals, then try other practices between sessions.
Coaching on this topic can cover:
- your own reflexes: do you decide too quickly, or take back work you delegated?
- the frame you set: goals, limits, levels of delegation;
- how your team responds to mistakes and proposals;
- practising a questioning stance.
Depending on the need, you can look for a leadership coach to work on your own approach, a team coach if the block is collective, or see the leadership development service. For senior leaders, an executive coach can also work on the relationship with the leadership team. Compare the training, approach and experience listed on each profile, and bring your questions to the first conversation. If your team works remotely, some of the levers change: see remote leadership in hybrid work.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between initiative and autonomy?
Autonomy is latitude granted by the organization: you can choose how to do your work. Initiative is behavior: setting your own goal, anticipating a problem and persisting despite obstacles. Someone can be autonomous without taking initiative, simply doing what is asked well. Autonomy makes initiative possible, but it does not create it on its own.
How can I encourage initiative without losing control?
Separate what is fixed from what is open. The leader sets the goal, the budget, the limits and the points where they want to be informed; inside that frame, the team chooses. The frame does not reduce initiative, it enables it, because everyone knows how far they can go without asking. Control then applies to outcomes and limits, not to every step.
Why don't my team members take initiative?
The cause often lies in the environment more than in the people: a past mistake that was punished, vague goals, sign-off required at every step, proposals left unanswered. Before concluding that motivation is lacking, look at what happens on your team to someone who proposes something or gets it wrong. A coach can help you take stock of this.
How long does it take to build initiative in a team?
No timeframe can be promised: it depends on the team's size, its history and the manager's consistency. Changes in practice (delegating a decision, answering every proposal, debriefing without looking for blame) can start the following week. Their effect on behavior shows over time, by watching whether proposals become more frequent.
Is coaching enough to develop initiative?
No. A coach helps a leader or a team see their practices and try others, but initiative also depends on the organization: approval processes, goals, and how senior management treats mistakes. Coaching guarantees no outcome. It is useful when the leader is willing to change their own way of leading, not only that of their team.
Sources
- Frese M., Fay D. (2001), Personal initiative: An active performance concept for work in the 21st century, Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 23
- Glaub M., Frese M., Fischer S., Hoppe M. (2014), Increasing personal initiative in small business managers or owners leads to entrepreneurial success, Academy of Management Learning and Education, vol. 13, no. 3
- Google re:Work (2015), Understand team effectiveness (Project Aristotle)
- International Coaching Federation (ICF), About ICF
Sources
Ready to take action?
Find the coach who matches your goal
Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.


