From Mentoring to Coaching: A Strategic Shift for Leaders
A mentor shares what worked for them; a coach helps leaders build their own answers when the situation is new. Here is what strategic leadership involves, how coaching develops it and how to set up the engagement.
8 min readUpdated on

Moving from mentoring to coaching is a strategic shift for leaders: a mentor shares what worked for them, while a coach helps you build your own answers to situations nobody has faced yet. Coaching for strategic leadership works on how you anticipate, challenge assumptions, interpret ambiguity, decide, align people and learn. The coach does not hand you a strategy.
What does strategic leadership actually involve?
Strategic leadership is more than setting quarterly targets. It is the ability to set a direction when the future is uncertain, to make choices that commit the organization for years and to bring others along. Operational leadership is about execution and day-to-day efficiency. Both matter, but the first requires regularly stepping out of the second.
In Harvard Business Review (January/February 2013), Paul Schoemaker, Steve Krupp and Samantha Howland described six skills of strategic leaders, drawing on research at the Wharton School and at their consulting firm involving more than 20,000 executives, according to the authors:
- Anticipate: spot possible shifts in your environment before they become obvious.
- Challenge: question assumptions, your own and the organization's.
- Interpret: make sense of ambiguous information.
- Decide: commit without waiting for a certainty that will not come.
- Align: win buy-in from people with different interests.
- Learn: draw lessons from your decisions, whether they worked or not.
Picture a sales director who redirects her team toward a new customer segment while current sales are holding, because she expects buying habits to change. She has to read weak signals, challenge the belief that what works today will keep working, decide without proof and persuade a team attached to its existing clients. Our article on the core principles of strategic leadership goes further.
Mentoring or coaching: which helps leaders think strategically?
The CIPD, the UK professional body for HR, separates the two. Coaching aims at performance and improvement at work; it is non-directive and focuses on specific skills and goals. In mentoring, a more experienced colleague shares their knowledge with someone less experienced, and these relationships tend to last longer than coaching arrangements.
| Criterion | Mentoring | Coaching |
|---|---|---|
| Who provides the answer | The mentor shares their experience | The person being coached builds their own |
| Who guides you | Someone more experienced in your field | Someone trained in coaching, not necessarily in your job |
| Duration | Often long term | Usually a defined period |
| Most useful when | You are learning a role or an organization | The situation is new, even for experienced people |
Many leaders move from one to the other as their careers progress. A mentor passes on what worked for them, yet strategic decisions often concern situations nobody in the company has met before. Coaching then works on how you reason rather than on the answer itself. The two combine well: a mentor for knowledge of the organization, a coach for the quality of your thinking. If you also want your managers to adopt this stance, read our piece on becoming a leader coach.
Coaching is not therapy either. The ICF Code of Ethics asks coaches to stay alert to signs that the relationship is no longer providing value and, where appropriate, to explore a different coach, professional or resource. Our guide to telling coaching and therapy apart helps you pick the right person.
What does a coach do to develop strategic leadership?
The International Coaching Federation (ICF) defines coaching as partnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential. Applied to strategy, the coach provides neither market analysis nor an action plan, but asks the questions that make a leader build and test their own reasoning.
An engagement often follows this sequence, adapted to each person:
- Bring a real strategic question. Your department's direction, an offer to rethink, the skills your key people will need. Arriving with that question changes the conversation, as our guide to preparing your first coaching session explains.
- Map your environment. Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats for the scope you are responsible for. The coach surfaces blind spots with questions such as "Which quiet trend could undermine our model?" or "What am I taking for granted without having checked?"
- Articulate a direction. Move from a vague intent ("become the market leader") to a direction your team can understand and act on. Our article on strategic vision in coaching covers this step.
- Turn it into decisions. First moves, tracking indicators, the message to your team, internal allies. Our guide to strategic decisions for leaders goes into detail.
- Adjust between sessions. Feedback from the field, resistance and new information feed the next session. This is where the "learn" skill gets practiced.
None of this looks like a training course: there is no standard content, the material is your own situation. To compare profiles, start with our leadership coaches and the leadership development service page.
What does research say about executive coaching?
A meta-analysis by Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen in The Journal of Positive Psychology (2014) pooled studies conducted in organizations. It found significant positive effects of coaching on five categories of individual outcomes: performance and skills, well-being, coping, work attitudes and goal-directed self-regulation. The authors conclude that coaching is, overall, an effective intervention in organizations. These are averages across studies; they say nothing about what a particular engagement will produce.
A systematic review by Athanasopoulou and Dopson, published in The Leadership Quarterly in 2018 and summarized by the Coaching Research Lab at the Weatherhead School of Management, stresses context. Its recommendations include learning the organization's social context (routines, structures, power dynamics) before sessions, using 360-degree feedback carefully and developmentally, and integrating coaching with other initiatives such as management training.
For a company paying for coaching, the practical consequence is to agree upfront on what you will observe: decisions taken, quality of trade-offs, feedback from the team. Our article on measuring the impact of coaching offers markers.
How do you choose a coach and set up the engagement?
- Training and credentials: ask which ones, from which body, and check with that body.
- Grasp of senior roles: the coach should understand executive-level trade-offs, without necessarily having run a company.
- Method: ask how they would work on your strategic question in the first sessions.
- Written agreement: the ICF Code asks coaches to co-create, before coaching starts, an agreement on roles, responsibilities, confidentiality and financial arrangements, and a clear agreement on what information is exchanged among all parties when an employer is involved.
Our guide to executive coaching walks through how an engagement unfolds. On EraCoach you can search coaches by specialty, for example among executive coaches, and book a session to bring your strategic question.
Frequently asked questions
How many sessions does strategic leadership coaching take?
There is no reference number. It depends on the question you bring, the pace of the decisions ahead and the framework your company sets if it pays. The most useful step is to agree at the outset on a number of sessions, review points to take stock, and the option to stop or extend based on what you observe.
Should I choose between a mentor and a coach?
No, they complement each other. According to the CIPD, a mentor shares greater experience than the person they support, while coaching is non-directive and focuses on specific skills and goals. A mentor helps you understand an organization; a coach helps you reason through a new situation where other people's experience no longer suffices.
Is strategic leadership coaching only for senior executives?
No. It also suits managers taking on a wider scope, experts promoted into leadership roles and founders whose companies are growing. What they share is a situation where execution is no longer enough: they have to choose a direction, arbitrate between priorities and persuade others to follow.
Can my employer pay for this coaching?
In France, it can, since leadership coaching can fall under employer-funded skills development. Three parties are then involved: you, the coach and the company. Put in writing what will and will not be shared with your employer. Other options are covered in our article on funding professional coaching.
What if coaching reveals exhaustion?
Coaching is not healthcare and makes no diagnosis. If fatigue or anxiety take over, the ICF Code invites the coach to consider another professional, such as a doctor or psychologist depending on the situation. Strategic work can resume later. For founders, our article on entrepreneur burnout offers guidance.
Sources
- Schoemaker, Krupp and Howland, "Strategic Leadership: The Essential Skills", Harvard Business Review, 2013
- International Coaching Federation, definition of coaching
- International Coaching Federation, Code of Ethics
- CIPD, Coaching and mentoring factsheet
- Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen, "Does coaching work?", The Journal of Positive Psychology, 2014
- Athanasopoulou and Dopson, systematic review, The Leadership Quarterly, 2018 (Coaching Research Lab summary)
Sources
Ready to take action?
Find the coach who matches your goal
Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.


