Transforming Managerial Practices: Embrace Evolutionary Leadership
Transformational coaching goes beyond a single goal: it works on how a manager understands their role, makes decisions and relates to their team. What it is, how it runs in a company, what research shows and how to choose a coach.
9 min readUpdated on

Transformational coaching is a form of professional coaching that goes beyond a single goal: it works on how a manager understands their role, makes decisions and relates to their team. It takes place in individual or group sessions, under a contract and a confidentiality agreement, with a professional coach from inside or outside the company.
What is transformational coaching, and how does it differ from the manager as coach?
"Transformational" describes an intention more than a method. Performance coaching targets a specific result: leading a negotiation, running a difficult meeting. A transformational approach looks at the assumptions that drive those behaviours: what the manager believes they must control, what they refuse to delegate, what they demand of themselves. The International Coaching Federation describes coaching as a "transformative journey" in which the client leads and the coach supports them in finding their own solutions through questioning and dialogue. Its French chapter, ICF France, defines coaching as an alliance between a coach and a client, meant to develop the client's thinking and creativity in order to maximise their professional and personal potential.
Why does this matter for managers in particular? Writing in the Harvard Business Review, Herminia Ibarra and Anne Scoular ("The Leader as Coach", 2019) start from an observation: with rapid, disruptive change, managers can no longer be expected to have all the answers, and command-and-control leadership is no longer viable. According to them, many firms are moving towards a model in which managers ask questions and offer support instead of giving orders. The authors compare directive, nondirective and situational coaching, and point out that sometimes no coaching at all is the appropriate choice.
So two different things share one vocabulary. Mixing them up leads to the wrong brief for the coach.
| Transformational coaching of a manager | The manager as coach | |
|---|---|---|
| Who coaches | A professional coach, internal or external | The manager |
| Who is coached | The manager, sometimes their team | Team members |
| Setting | Contract, written goals, confidentiality | The day-to-day reporting relationship |
| What is worked on | Beliefs, stance, ways of deciding | The team's autonomy and problem solving |
The two fit together: a manager who has worked on their own stance can then practise asking instead of telling. For that second approach, see our articles on becoming a leader coach and on six levers of manager coaching. If what you need is expert advice or someone passing on their experience, a coach is not the right professional: our guide to the differences between coaching, mentoring and consulting explains where each one fits.
How does a managerial transformation coaching engagement run inside a company?
In an organisation, three parties are involved: the manager, the coach and the company that commissions and pays, usually called the sponsor. An engagement typically moves through five stages.
- Clarify the request. The company states what it wants to see change and why now: a reorganisation, hybrid work, new digital tools, a broader remit. A vague request produces a vague contract.
- Meet several coaches. The manager chooses the person they will work with. A first conversation is the place to check that the method and the relationship suit them.
- Sign a three-way agreement. The code of ethics published by ICF France (2025 version) requires the coach, before coaching begins, to explain the nature of the process and to co-create an agreement covering roles, responsibilities, confidentiality and financial arrangements. Each party may end the engagement at any time, subject to the terms of that agreement.
- Work in session, then experiment. The coach questions, reframes and challenges. Between sessions, the manager tries something different with the team: handing over a decision, running a meeting another way, asking for feedback. That back-and-forth is where the work happens.
- Review. The three parties meet to look at what has shifted against the written goals, and what still needs attention.
Confidentiality holds the whole structure together. The same code requires the coach to keep the strictest level of confidentiality towards all parties involved, and to agree clearly on what information is exchanged and how it is shared. The contract therefore spells out what goes back to the sponsor and what stays between coach and manager.
When a company wants to extend the approach to a whole management line, Ibarra and Scoular (Harvard Business Review, 2019) recommend four moves: articulate why coaching is valuable, have leaders embrace and model it, build coaching skills across the ranks, and remove barriers to change. Group work can then sit alongside individual sessions: see our article on transformational coaching for teams and the page listing team coaches.
Then comes the budget. In France, the official Service-Public.fr page on the skills development plan (checked on 13 March 2026) states that training under the plan is initiated by the employer, that the employer bears the cost and that pay is maintained during working hours. That page does not mention coaching, so a company has to check whether the engagement it has in mind falls within that framework. Other routes are covered in our guide to funding professional coaching.
What does research say about the effects of workplace coaching?
Studies look at coaching in organisations in general, not at the "transformational" label. According to the meta-analysis by Theeboom, Beersma and van Vianen in The Journal of Positive Psychology (2014), listed by Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, "coaching has significant positive effects on all outcomes" examined: performance and skills, well-being, coping, work attitudes and goal-directed self-regulation. Reported effect sizes range from g = 0.43 for coping to g = 0.74 for goal-directed self-regulation. The authors also note that research has lagged behind practice and that studies often lack a solid theoretical basis.
A second meta-analysis, by Jones, Woods and Guillaume in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology (2016), available through Aston University, covers 17 studies of coaching delivered by internal or external coaches. It leaves out coaching of a subordinate by their own manager. It reports a positive overall effect on organisational outcomes (δ = 0.36), stronger effects with internal coaches than with external ones, and no significant effect of coaching format or duration.
These figures are averages across groups. They show that the practice has been evaluated seriously, not what any one manager will take from it: that depends on their commitment, on the relationship with the coach and on how much the organisation actually lets them change.
How do you choose a coach for a managerial transformation?
A coach's credentials are checked item by item. Five points deserve a direct question in the first conversation.
- Training and credential. ICF France states that its credential follows a single process common to all countries and is renewed every three years, which attests to continuing education. Ask which level the coach holds and since when. Our article on ICF, EMCC and HEC coaching credentials helps you read those labels.
- The code of ethics they follow. A coach who belongs to a federation can name the code they apply and explain how they handle confidentiality with a sponsor.
- Knowledge of your context. Coaching a front-line manager on a production site and a director at head office do not call on the same references. Ask for examples of comparable situations, without names.
- Clarity about limits. Coaching is neither therapy nor diagnosis. The ICF code asks coaches to recognise their limits and, when the benefit of coaching changes, to consider with the client another professional or another resource.
- A method explained without promises. A serious coach describes what will happen in sessions and how goals will be tracked. They do not put a number on an outcome in advance.
On EraCoach you can search by specialty or by city. For managerial transformation, the closest pages are those for leadership coaches and executive coaches, along with the leadership development service. Read each profile for what it actually says about the coach's training and background.
Sources
- International Coaching Federation, "What is coaching" (accessed 10 October 2026).
- ICF France: definition of coaching and credential renewal (accessed 10 October 2026).
- ICF France, code of ethics, 2025 version (accessed 10 October 2026).
- Ibarra H. and Scoular A., "The Leader as Coach", Harvard Business Review, 97 (6), 2019, London Business School record.
- Theeboom T., Beersma B. and van Vianen A., "Does coaching work?", The Journal of Positive Psychology, 9 (1), 2014.
- Jones R., Woods S. and Guillaume Y., "The effectiveness of workplace coaching", Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 89 (2), 2016.
- Service-Public.fr, skills development plan, page checked on 13 March 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between transformational coaching and regular coaching?
The difference lies in how deep the work goes. Goal-focused coaching deals with one specific situation: a presentation, a conflict, a new role. Coaching described as transformational also examines the beliefs and habits that produce those situations. A single engagement can combine both, and the label matters less than what the contract says.
How long does managerial transformation coaching take?
There is no standard length: it depends on the goal, the pace of sessions and the time left between them to experiment. The meta-analysis by Jones, Woods and Guillaume (2016, Aston University) found no significant effect of duration on measured outcomes. The number of sessions is set in the contract: see how many coaching sessions to plan.
Is transformational coaching a form of therapy?
No. Coaching addresses professional goals: it makes no diagnosis and does not treat psychological distress. The code of ethics of ICF France (2025 version) asks coaches to recognise their limits and, where needed, to consider with the client another professional or another resource. A serious coach says so in the very first conversation.
Who pays for a manager's coaching: the company or the employee?
When the company initiates the coaching, it signs the contract and pays the coach as sponsor. A manager can also pay for their own coaching, which leaves them full choice of coach and goals. Funding routes are set out in our guide to funding professional coaching, linked earlier on this page.
Can the effects of transformational coaching be measured?
You can track indicators agreed at the start: observable behaviours, feedback from the team, goals met or not. Available studies measure average effects across groups, not an individual result. A review with the sponsor, without disclosing what was said in sessions, shows what has changed and what still needs work.
Ready to take action?
Find the coach who matches your goal
Hand-picked certified coaches. Free first discovery session, no commitment.


